Phoenix Law Enforcement Association

Cop Killer Denied Clemency Again

On January 8, 1986, Phoenix Police Officer Robert T. Fike was shot and killed by Matthew Milburn shortly after Officer Fike contacted him while he was inside a vehicle parked behind the Circle K Store located at 1111 East Indian School Road.

Milburn was no stranger to trouble and already had already served time in the Arizona Department of Corrections for burglary.  Earlier, he committed an armed robbery and was using cocaine when Officer Fike contacted him.  A struggle occurred while Officer Fike was patting Milburn down, and Officer Fike was disarmed before being shot and killed execution style.  Shortly afterwards, two citizens came upon Officer Fike’s patrol car and found his lifeless body on the ground next to it, then called for help using the police radio.  Milburn was eventually located and taken into custody seven weeks after the shooting after investigators developed enough information to tie him to the murder.  Milburn initially denied his involvement and blamed an unnamed and still unknown co-conspirator, but later admitted he was responsible for Officer Fike’s death. Milburn accepted a plea bargain, which spared him from the death penalty, was sentenced to life in prison and began serving his term on July 3, 1986.

At the time of his death, Officer Fike was a 10 year veteran of the Phoenix Police Department and had been back on the streets in Patrol for just two weeks after choosing to leave an undercover assignment for a schedule which would allow him to spend more time with his wife and two sons.

Since Milburn is serving a life sentence, he is eligible to annually apply to the Arizona Board of Executive Clemency for parole.   Under the current state of emergency declared by Governor Ducey, Milburn’s hearing was held via teleconference earlier this morning.  PLEA Secretary Frank Marino, a representative from the County Attorney’s Office, one of Officer Fike’s friends and Officer Fike’s brother-in-law all testified on behalf of Officer Fike, his family, Phoenix Police Officers and all police officers.  As was the case last year, the Clemency Board unanimously voted to deny parole for Milburn.  The Board’s newest member, Mina Mendez, a former Maricopa County Superior Court Judge, specifically pointed out Milburn’s well-documented history of continued misconduct while in custody of the Arizona Department of Corrections, including significant violations within the past six months, the fact that Officer Fike’s murder was cold blooded and one of the worst cases she has reviewed, and despite being incarcerated for over 33 years, Milburn still poses a serious risk to the community.   

PLEA will always strive to attend these hearings to be a voice and advocate for our officers who can no longer speak for themselves and their family members who are forced to relive and experience the gut-wrenching memories of the event.